The service has always been outstanding, the food is fresh and oh so tasty, and the menu has fantastic options. They have the BEST French Onion Soup I have ever had, and an incredible Wedge Salad. Holy. Moly. Now I am hungry and wish I could get over to My Way Tavern in Holly Springs RIGHT NOW! My Way Tavern, right on Main St. in Holly Springs is absolutely one of my favorite stops these days.
I have tried My Way Tavern several times and always at different times of day. Sometimes I’ve been with a friend, and other times we’ve taken the whole family in, small children included. I’ve been pleased with the service every. single. time. The staff is always friendly and helpful with menu and attentive to your needs at the table. They check on you just enough to make sure you’re taken care of, but not so much that it’s annoying. I’m definitely more of a food customer than a bar customer, but that doesn’t change the fact that this place is great.
The atmosphere inside My Way is definitely laid back. You don’t need to dress up and it seems like the goal is to get you to come in and relax. A large U shaped bar is centerpiece for the space, but I don’t feel uncomfortable taking my kids in during mealtime. If you go during peak times, be ready to wait just a little. Seating is a bit limited here, but a little wait is worth it. When you arrive, see if there are any tables that fit you available. If not, write your name on the chalkboard. I haven’t had to do this yet, but I can see it happening sometime soon as much as I love this place. If you’re looking for a quiet romantic evening, this wouldn’t necessarily be my recommendation since it can be a little noisy. I still love it for date nights though. Who says hitting up trivia on Tuesdays wouldn’t be a fun night out?!?
The My Way Tavern menu is a mix of typical bar food with a few upscale touches. Most everything is made in house (it MIGHT be everything, but I don’t know for sure…) and their ranch and blue cheese salad dressings are AWESOME! Burgers come with all kinds of different toppings and options and are cooked to order. Salads are fresh and the Wedge at My Way is perfect. A hunk of lettuce with their house made blue cheese, bacon, tomatoes, crispy fried onions, and the most amazing bread on the side. (Seriously SO hungry now!) The French Onion Soup is such an old school classic, and one of my favorite things. My Way’s might be the best I’ve ever had. The Crab Stuffed Portabella appitizer is another great pick for your meal or as an app to share with the table. Wonderful deli sandwiches, delicious salads, full entrees, and more. There are so many things on the menu that I want to go back and try.
While My Way Tavern is very family friendly, they don’t have a specific kids menu. My tip for you is that the hot dog plate (which you can add a dog to and split between 2 kids) is perfect. I would imagine the chicken tenders appitizer (also house made) is another great “kids meal” option.
Great food, great service, and a casual, relaxed atmosphere: all found at My Way Tavern in Holly Springs.